Integrity, Information, & Innovation

Helping you Plan for the Future

Affordable Insurance from Your Independent Insurance Agent

Contact Lancaster Insurance Agency of Evansville, IN, where integrity and innovation result in the most affordable insurance tailored to your precise needs. We're a private agency for many different insurance providers and specialize in finding policies that are right for you. Whether you require auto, home, or business insurance, we will discuss your policy options with you to make sure you have everything that you need.  We also specialized in high risks and SR 22’s and have policies at a price you can afford. 

We know you have questions, and plenty of concerns, and our agents are extremely knowledgeable and helpful when it comes to meeting all the needs of your personal or business liabilities.  We discuss options such as bundling home, auto and umbrellas for special discount rates and we are always looking for ways to save you money.   We are only a phone call away when you need us.

Our mission is to be your support system and to arm you with the best information so you make the right insurance coverage decisions. Whether you are buying a home or car or starting up a new business, we are here to help protect your future with the expertise our clients have come to expect. What a nice, secure feeling it is to know that you're fully covered with services from Lancaster Insurance Agency.

Contact us today to discuss your insurance needs.

(812) 477-8883


Contact us today to schedule an appointment or to discuss your insurance needs.

(812) 477-8883

Hours of Operation
Monday - Friday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM

658 S Green River Rd
Evansville, IN 47715

Service Area
Indiana and Kentucky